Monday, December 14, 2015

The COP21 Agreement is a Momentous Leap Forward

The agreement signed in Paris is the most significant achievement in the history of climate action.. The world has come together to agree on a  31-page deal that lays a solid foundation for serious climate action. The signing of the Paris accord signals the start of globally coordinated efforts to reign-in climate change. History will record that the deal was signed at the 21st Session of the Conference of the Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (COP21) on December 12, 2015.

Imperfect deal

There are a number of imperfections in the Paris agreement, not the least of which is the fact that the submitted INDCs will not prevent the earth from warming more than the internationally agreed upon 2 degree Celsius upper threshold limit. The agreed upon levels of mitigation financing including damage and loss for vulnerable nations is inadequate. 

There really was no choice, as UN general-secretary Ban Ki moon said, perfection is the enemy of this climate agreement. We had to compromise to get the deal done.

Some are disappointed that the agreement reiterates the 2 degree Celsius (3.6 degrees Fahrenheit) upper threshold rather than focusing exclusively on achieving the 1.5 degree Celsius limit that was supported by many nations including the US, Canada, China and the EU. The text says we must stay well below 2C and strive to keep global temperatures from rising more than 1.5 degrees Celsius.

It would also have been desirable to make emissions reduction legally binding. However due to Republican obstructionism in the Senate, these targets will not be binding under international law. However, other aspects of the deal will be legally binding.


While the agreement is less than perfect, it is nonetheless a historic achievement that gives us reason to believe that the world may finally tackle the climate crisis. More than ever before, the Paris agreement shows that we can muster the will to act together on climate change.

It is naive to have expected that COP21 on its own could have produced a final agreement that would have definitively ended climate change. The deal demanded compromises, nonetheless, we have taken a massive step forward.

Failure to produce an agreement would have squandered the momentum of COP21. The outcome is an objective reflection of how far we have come. It will also galvanize support to further the process.

The Paris deal should not be cast as a baby step forward, it is a gargantuan leap that buoys our hope that we can prevail.


Despite this great achievement, the deal has attracted the attention of a number of critics.

As explained by US President Barack Obama long before the deal was signed, cynicism is the enemy of climate action. "One of the enemies we will be fighting at this conference is cynicism – the presumption that we can't do anything about climate change," he said.

Even before the ink was dry, the cynics were crawling out of the woodwork to deride the agreement. One online rag even called it "an epic fail on a planetary scale."

Klein's carping

Modern day Marxist revolutionary Naomi Klein is a COP21 cynic on steroids. She did not wait for the deal to be signed to launch into a tirade. As we were on the cusp of signing the most important climate deal in history, she railed against it and amplified her calls to overthrow the capitalist system.

"The deal that will be unveiled in less than a week, likely to much fanfare and self-congratulation from politicians, echoed by an overly deferential press, will not be enough to keep us safe. In fact, it will be extraordinarily dangerous," Klein said

The only thing that is extraordinarily dangerous is Klein's contrarian whining. As a leading voice of the revolutionary narrative, Klein is dangerous because pessimistic rants undermine environmental advocacy.

Hansen's curmudgeonly views

James Hansen is a great man, he has been a stalwart champion of climate action and for this we should all be grateful. He has a better grasp of the science than almost anyone so we should listen when he sounds the alarm about such things as the inadequacy of the 2C upper threshold limit. However, the former Nasa scientist holds curmudgeonly views on COP21.

"It’s a fraud really, a fake," Hansen said. "It’s just bullshit for them to say: ‘We’ll have a 2C warming target and then try to do a little better every five years.’ It’s just worthless words. There is no action, just promises. As long as fossil fuels appear to be the cheapest fuels out there, they will be continued to be burned."

His take may be born out of his passionate convictions, but it is patently untrue and ultimately destructive to popular support for the climate movement. Although it may not be his intention, his comments provide fodder for those who seek to derail political action.

In the past he has quite rightly launched scathing attacks against leading Republicans, but his attacks now include President Obama who has done more to advance climate action in the US than any American ever has. Hansen is undeniably one of the world's leading climate scientists and a powerful activist, however, his failure to understand the political and psychological realities at play in the war against climate change harms the broader cause.

Historic achievement

Rather than criticize, we should take a brief moment to appreciate the scale of this unprecedented accomplishment. Millions signed petitions and on the weekend before the talks, hundreds of thousands took to the streets to call for an ambitious deal. People wanted an agreement and world leaders delivered.

The COP21 deal has achieved the goal of setting verifiable commitments to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and it has established rules for how countries monitor and report their emissions and reductions. In short, we have an international agreement that was signed by 196 countries that will limit the global temperature and hold governments to account.

Even before the talks began thousands of companies, cities, regions and investors committed to significant emission reductions. Getting so many to agree is a virtually impossible task. As UN secretary-general Ban Ki-moon said at the outset of the talks, "It will not be easy to get everyone to sign-on and many challenges must be overcome."

Despite these challenges and even a terrorist attack, a deal was forged.  Not only did the Paris agreement meet expectations, it exceeded them.

Signal to markets

One of the most important dimensions of this deal is the message that it sends to the private sector. The end of the old energy economy is now in sight and the low carbon economy is here to stay. Businesses will need to prepare for a raft of government regulation and those companies that have already invested in sustainability stand to reap lucrative dividends. 

As reported by the Guardian, Jennifer Morgan, of the environmental think tank the World Resources Institute, said the long term goal was "transformational" and "sends signals into the heart of the markets".

The Paris deal will expedite the demise of the fossil fuel industry and invigorate investment in renewable energy. This is a clarion call and both large and small investors will need to review their portfolios. This seismic shift was confirmed by the International Investors Group on Climate Change, a network managing €13 trillion of assets. They said they expect to see movement away from fossil fuels and and towards renewable energy. 

More cuts to come

The Paris deal is only the beginning. “It’s not the end of the fight over liability, it’s put the polluters on notice and that fight will continue in other fora,” said former US Vice President Al Gore.

The new agreement includes provisions to ratchet up national ambitions over time.  “Paris has to be a catalyst. It’s in no way, shape, or form a final chapter.” said Derek Walker, associate vice president of global climate at the Environmental Defense Fund.

As reported by the Guardian, a White House official said, "We can’t go home and say ’we saved the planet, check.’ This issue will continue to be a top priority for the President and the White House coming out of Paris heading into next year and for remaining time that he is in office because there is more work to do."

After most world leaders left Paris, president Obama stayed behind and worked towards legally binding periodic reviews of each country's emissions reduction targets. As part of the final COP21 deal, nations have committed themselves to reviewing their national emissions reduction pledges every five years. This prompted Miguel Arias Cañete, the EU’s climate commissioner to say that we can build on this historic deal.

This Paris agreement specifically asks governments to periodically strengthen their emissions reduction pledges in order to meet and exceed the goal of keeping temperatures below the 2C upper threshold limit.

Zero emissions

The agreement is both a first step and the turning point for our efforts to curtail and ultimately eliminate greenhouse gas emissions.

"This means bringing down greenhouse gas emissions to net zero within a few decades," said John Schellnhuber, director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, and a climate adviser to the Vatican.

The deal should be scrutinized, but let's take a moment to appreciate that we are about to take the first bold steps towards a carbon free future.

Source: Global Warming is Real

COP21 is an Unprecedented Turning Point
Unpacking the COP21 Paris Climate Agreement (Infographic)
The COP21 Climate Deal and the Crucial Role of Obama's Leadership (Video)
Republican's Failed Attempts to Undermine the COP21 Climate Agreement
Paris Terror Attacks Climate Change and COP21
Breaking: We Have a Final Draft Climate Agreement at COP21 
As We Near the End of COP21 People are Demanding Climate Action
Optimism at COP21 Despite Disagreements on the Meaning of Differentiated Responsibilities
Being Hopeful About the COP21 Climate Deal (Video)
Canadian Leadership at COP21
COP21 Compact of States and Regions Pledges Emissions Reductions Equivalent to China's Annual Output
A Guide to COP21 and Clean Energy Solutions from 24 Hours of Reality and Live Earth (Video)
Al Gore Says COP21 Will be a Turning Point in Global Policy (Video)
COP21 and Stranded Fossil Fuel Assets
COP21 History and Guides
COP21 Starts With Pledges of Action from World Leaders
President Obama's Address at the Opening Session of COP21
Everything You Need to Know About COP21 (Video)
Summary of the Final Round of Climate Talks Before COP21

No comments: